Protected by anti-Muslim ruling, Trump defeats protesters in lawsuit
Staff Host Account
/ Categories: Islam Times-English

Protected by anti-Muslim ruling, Trump defeats protesters in lawsuit

A federal appeals court on Tuesday shot down a lawsuit filed by protesters Henry Brousseau, Kashiya Nwanguma and Molly Shah, who say they were aggressively ejected from a rally in Louisville, Kentucky in March 2016. Judges David McKeague and Richard Griffin cited a 2015 ruling in which an anti-Muslim protest was constitutionally protected. They argued in an opinion that Trump did not actually call for violence. "In the ears of some supporters, Trump’s words may have had a tendency to elicit a physical response, in the event a disruptive protester refused to leave, but they did not specifically advocate such a response," it read. "As to how the offensive words were said, we know, most relevantly, by plaintiffs’ own allegations, that the words were accompanied by the admonition, 'don’t hurt ’em.' That this undercuts the alleged violence-inciting sense of Trump’s words can hardly be denied." The protesters named Trump as defendant along with three of his supporters, including a white supremacist in attendance. "The same can be said of Trump’s speech in this case: not a single word encouraged violence or lawlessness, explicitly or implicitly," read the opinion. "It follows that if Trump’s speech is protected — because it, like that of the Bible Believers, did not include a single word encouraging violence — then the fact that audience members reacted by using force does not transform Trump’s protected speech into unprotected speech. The reaction of listeners does not alter the otherwise protected nature of speech." The third judge, Helene White, did not support the argument that Trump's call to oust the demonstrators was protected by the First Amendment. "The majority opinion elides salient details of Trump’s speech that make this a closer case for me than for the majority and overemphasizes the legal significance of the 'don’t hurt ‘em' statement," White wrote.
Previous Article Rogue US regime's boorishness boundless: Iran FM
Next Article Trump cancels visit to Ireland after groups announce planned protests
Print
57 Rate this article:
No rating

Leave a comment

Add comment

x
«November 2018»
MonTueWedThuFriSatSun
29
Muslim Homeschool Curriculum Choices | 1st & 3rd Grade | Charlotte Mason

Muslim Homeschool Curriculum Choices | 1st & 3rd Grade | Charlotte Mason

Muslim Homeschool Curriculum Choices | 1st & 3rd Grade | Charlotte MasonOur Muslim homeschool curriculum choices for my 8 and 6 year old children. I have created a curriculum that I believe in and that aligns with our values. CLICK HERE: https://wp.me/p8wklJ-23q WATCH Ronni's Video on Multicultural Motherhood: https://www.youtu.be/9GcqNRUwO08 For more information about this curriculum and extensive book lists, Read the CO-ORDINATING BLOG_POST: https://wp.me/p8wklJ-23q Homeschool History: https://youtu.be/NvyQbrh_Zec Teaching Arabic: https://youtu.be/VqPgjFdB6xA Picture Study: https://youtu.be/6TRAynK8yZw Touch-Typing: https://wp.me/p8wklJ-22N Other Places to Find me: Blog: http://ourmuslimhomeschool.com/ Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/ourmuslimho... Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/ourmuslimhom... Twitter: https://twitter.com/OurMHomeschool Thanks for watching!
Read more
30311
23
4
5
6
7
891011
12
1314
15
1617
18
19202122232425
262728293012
3456789